My Thoughts On: The Selection by Kiera Cass

Posted January 20, 2012 by Asheley in Uncategorized / 15 Comments

The Selection (The Selection #1) by Kiera Cass
Published by HarperTeen

Publish Date:  April 24, 2012 
327 Pages
Source:  Borrowed

For thirty-five girls, the Selection is the chance of a lifetime. The opportunity to escape the life laid out for them since birth. To be swept up in a world of glittering gowns and priceless jewels. To live in the palace and compete for the heart of the gorgeous Prince Maxon. 

But for America Singer, being Selected is a nightmare. It means turning her back on her secret love with Aspen, who is a caste below her. Leaving her home to enter a fierce competition for a crown she doesn’t want. Living in a palace that is constantly threatened by violent rebel attacks. 

Then America meets Prince Maxon. Gradually, she starts to question all the plans she’s made for herself- and realizes that the life she’s always dreamed of may not compare to a future she never imagined.  
-(summary from

The Selection by Kiera Cass

My Thoughts: When I first saw the cover of The Selection by Kiera Cass, I knew I wanted to read it. After all, I’m a cover girl. Then when I started reading the book, I absolutely felt like I was reading a fairy tale and I was pretty much sold within the first few pages. Friends, I can almost bet that this book will end up a favorite of mine for 2012. I loved it

Why you should put The Selection on your wish list. NOW.

1. The Characters. I love them so much. So, so much. All of them — the good, the bad, and the ugly. 

  • America. 16-year-old female protagonist. Madly in love with Aspen, but this is basically forbidden as he is a lower caste than America (a Five). America is strong and unselfish, as she is willing to possibly give up part of her dreams and wishes for the advancement of her family and their needs…but she is also impulsive and immature at times (like every other girl her age), acting out rashly toward Aspen with feelings of misplaced hurt and anger.  
  • Aspen. In love with America, and boy does he love her fiercely! (sigh sigh sigh…) Aspen is a Six, meaning he is part of the lowest social grouping in Illea. Their love affair is basically forbidden and if they are caught meeting after curfew, they would be in tons of trouble. Aspen is described as a handsome, dark-haired boy that wears jeans and old shirts. Love him! 
  • Prince Maxon. We all know what a prince is, and this one needs a wife. He is nothing that America expects him to be and he is everything that we know a prince to be. He is kind, patient, and witty. He is described as a handsome, light-haired, well-mannered boy that wears official royal attire and rules alongside his father. He is pretty much the opposite of Aspen. Love this one too! 
2. The Story. Like I just said earlier, this book reads like a fairy tale – WHICH I LOVED – so if you’re a fan of classic fairy tales, I’m pretty sure you’ll like this one if you give it the chance. I don’t typically care for book comparisons, and I rarely compare books myself, so I wasn’t too thrilled with the blurb that circulated comparing this book to The Bachelor TV show and The Hunger Games. I have never watched The Bachelor, so I can’t comment on any similarities in that area. As far as The Hunger Games goes, the similarities are few if any (in my opinion). The Selection stands heavily and firmly on its own

3. The Selection. All girls in Illea between the ages of 16-20 have the opportunity to submit themselves as entries in The Selection process to become the next Princess of Illea, wife of Prince Maxon. Nearly all of the girls in America’s province have submitted forms because even if they make it into the 35 selected, they are compensated…and all of the families are in dire need of financial assistance. Not only that, but making it as far as the 35 automatically elevates you to a higher social caste, which means greater financial opportunity and helps the family as well. 

Some of the girls enter solely because of the monetary compensation and to be able to assist their families. Some of the girls enter because they want the crown. Some of the girls enter because they want to be Prince Maxon’s wife. The Selection process is supposed to weed out the ones that are there for the wrong reasons and find the one who would be the best wife for the Prince and the best royal for the province. 

Even knowing how much it would help her family if she made it into The Selection, America still is not interested because she believes she has found her true love in Aspen. Eventually Aspen convinces America to enter, giving reason that he would never forgive himself if she had the opportunity to at least try to make life better for herself but never did because of him. America agrees to fill out the form and see what happens…after all, they certainly won’t pick her, right? 

Well, America is indeed picked. Just before she leaves, she and Aspen have a huge argument and they part on bad terms. Aspen doesn’t get the chance to say some things he needs to say and America doesn’t give him the chance to talk…these mistakes set in motion events that will change both of their lives forever. 

4. Love Triangle? Maybe, maybe not. People will have varying opinions of whether this qualifies or not. We know that America loves Aspen desperately, but when she left for the castle – she was angry with him. We then watch America learn that she just might be able to love this Prince and this lifestyle that she thought she despised. And OH MY GRACIOUS you just can’t even imagine what happens next! 

Normally when there are two choices for a love interest, I can easily make my choice for a favorite. IN THIS CASE, I CANNOT! I honestly can say that I adore both Aspen and Prince Maxon. I desperately want America to end up with the both of them, but we all know that cannot happen, which brings me to…

5. The Ending. Left wide open! It isn’t a cliffhanger (thank goodness!) but The Selection process is not over yet. The ending is solid enough to keep readers literally hanging on until the next book is out so we can find out what is next for America, Aspen, Prince Maxon, and the war-torn country that he represents. 

6. The Cover. No comment necessary as it is gorgeous and very Southern-looking. 

I’m interested in the classification of this book as dystopian…I’ve seen it around. It certainly isn’t heavy on the dystopian, but there are a few (of what I would consider) dystopian characteristics: there is a definitive caste system in place. At first, the caste system is a little bit tricky to understand, but the more it is talked about, the easier it is to grasp. The castes are numbered (from One to Eight) with the lower numbers being the higher social status. In this society, it is better to be a One than an Eight… There are also some mandated rules that are punishable by law–things such as careers being specific to your caste and no sex until marriage…things like that. So while I don’t think I would necessarily call The Selection dystopian, there are some things about the government and the society that are reminiscent of a book in this genre.

Also, it is totally worth saying that America shows some awesome character development in using her position in The Selection process. She makes life better for lots of people with some of her words and some of her actions, and the more she began to do that, the more I liked her. Pardon the cliche, but it was as if she was becoming a “champion of the people” and there are so many places the author can take that in the next book…

You guys, this book absolutely blew me away. I wanted to hug it and dance around with it and sleep with it under my pillow so I could dream about it. I could not stop reading it! I felt like I had stepped right into a fairy tale and was living in the castle myself. I felt like I was walking the streets of Illea and experiencing the hunger and degradation of the people based on the caste system. I felt like I was watching The Selection take place from the inside, only I wasn’t competing. I literally loved every second of this reading experience…

…so when I finished The Selection, I promptly got onto Twitter to tell everyone how much I loved this book and found out about the recent controversy surrounding it…the controversy that was going down literally while I was living the fairy tale! What a bummer! BUT I tend to and stay out of the drama, and I will not let it ruin this tremendous story for me. For those of you who are like-minded and want a FANTASTIC book to read, I cannot stress to you enough how much you will love The Selection. Drama aside, this is one of the best books I’ve read in a very long time, and I do not anticipate remaining very patient while I wait until the next book is released. 

The Selection will appeal to fans of

Fairy Tales 
 Slowly developing YA romance  
Swoon-worthy love interests
Fierce competition 
(for the crown & the heart of the Prince)
Dystopian genre (possibly)

The Selection by Kiera Cass will be released on April 24, 2012.

*I borrowed this book as part of Around The World Book Tours in exchange for my honest thoughts and opinions. I received no compensation for my review.   

About Asheley

Asheley is a Southern girl. She loves Carolina blue skies, Ben & Jerry's ice cream, and NC craft beer. She loves all things history but prefers books over everything.

You can find her somewhere in North Carolina, daydreaming about the ocean.

Find Asheley on Litsy @intothehallofbooks!


15 responses to “My Thoughts On: The Selection by Kiera Cass

  1. OH YAY! I'm so glad to have read your review because I just finished this one and LOVED it. I read some not so positive reviews for it the other day, so I'm really excited to know you enjoyed it as much as I did. And I'm with you on not being able to choose between Aspen and Maxon. I usually can always pick one I like more, but I'm genuinely torn in this case and I love that! Really outstanding review Asheley, it just made me happy:)

  2. OMG! Ever since I saw this cover on someone's "Waiting on Wednesday" I've reeeeeaaally wanted to read it. Now that I know it has your stamp of approval (a probable fav of 2012 – whoa!) April just cannot get here soon enough!

  3. Jac

    I've been hearing a lot of complaints about the dystopian (or lack there of) aspect of this book. I'm glad that I know that going into this, because I don't think it will bother me now.

    I'm glad to hear that it's a slow-forming romance – your review has definitely made me more excited for this one!

    -Jac @ For Love and Books

  4. I can't believe I wasn't following you before now! Anywho, I'm SO glad you loved this. I've been looking forward to it, but I've heard a few people say they were disappointed by it. I'm glad to hear it really is all it's cracked up to be :]

  5. I'm really excited to read this novel! I fell in love with it's pretty cover, and to hear that you enjoyed it definitely got me looking forward to it 🙂

  6. I heard you saying you loved this one on Twitter the other day and before I even begin reading your review, I can tell you did because it is LONG! 🙂

    I love the names Aspen & America! 🙂

    I skimmed your review (I do this sometimes if I haven't read a book yet) and you've got me smiling about this book! Great review Asheley!

  7. I seriously wasn't going to read this one, after all the drama surrounding it. Of course, that particular review was the only on I had read at the time. I think though after your review I'm going to give it a shot.. I may not buy it, but borrow it for sure.

    I'm just now checking out your review style. it's been a hectic weekend. April is right, your lists rock! Very easy to read, and different. I like different. the same old kind of reviews become boring.. I think that's why I frequent Aprils blog so much because she is so outspoken in hers, and I love that. I will be coming to yours all the time now too! 🙂

    Hope you have a great day!

  8. I'm still torn on whether I want to read The Selection or not. Your review certainly makes a compelling case for it, but then I think of the drama and that really bothers me — like I'd rather read books by authors who respect both positive and negative reviews. But then again, I love reality tv and romance and while I dislike love triangles, sometimes a really well written one can slip through my radar.

Have a thought? Speak your mind!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.